A Review of “Use of Research Evidence by Criminal Justice Professionals”

Timothy Daty, University of New Haven 

This article previously appeared in ACJS Today. Permission was granted to republish it here.

In the recent issue of Justice Policy Journal, Johnson and colleagues explore the use of research evidence by criminal justice professionals. In particular, the researchers discuss the underutilization of research evidence into policies and practices. Evidence-based practices serve an important role in the development and continued success of criminal justice policies and practices. Through use of research evidence, the criminal justice system can better understand the impact of various programs and develop targeted strategies. In the absence of these evidence-based practices, strategies are at a much higher risk of failing or even worsening a current situation. For criminal justice practitioners, successfully integrating this research into policy decisions can be accomplished in variety of ways. In this article, the authors provide a thorough review of current practices and describe different ways of improving evidence-based practices. To do so, three core issues are addressed in this article: the research-practice gap in the criminal justice system, strategies for increasing the use of research evidence in decision-making, and suggestions for future research.

 In regards to the research-practice gap, the authors cite the relationship between researchers and practitioners and the distinct characteristics associated with each profession. Due to the nature of each profession, a disconnect may arise in how a researcher and a practitioner approach a specific issue. For a practitioner, they may view the work of a researcher as too theoretical. Alternatively, a researcher may assume that practitioners refuse to utilize scholarship due to their own personal, cultural, political, or economic goals. As a result, this can lead to several challenges in the integration of research-based practices.

In response to this, the researchers offer several recommendations to increase the use of research evidence in decision-making. Among their suggestions, Johnson and colleagues discuss how academic scholars can utilize field professionals, improve research dissemination, and pursue joint action with field professionals. In addition, the authors cite the findings from other research studies concerning the successful implementation of research into policies. A core theme present throughout this section is the researcher/practitioner relationship. Improving these relationships would strengthen collaborative efforts and close the research-practice gap.

Lastly, this research articles offers several suggestions for future research. Johnson and colleagues call for further research into the researcher/practitioner relationship. The dynamic between these two parties can impact the effectiveness of evidence-based practices. Exploring these issues could reveal how research is utilized and why decision-makers may be reluctant to incorporate research findings.

The full article may be found at:  http://www.cjcj.org/uploads/cjcj/documents/use_of_research_evidence_by_criminal_justice_professionals_johnson.pdf

Photos from photographers on Unsplash

Recent Articles

Quarterly for Evidence-Based Professionals - Volume 7, Number 1

Quarterly for Evidence-Based Professionals - Volume 7, Number 1

| EBP Quarterly
The EBP Quarterly - Volume 7, Number 1 This issue features timely and in-depth research articles. Enjoy... Problems ...
Problems and Solutions for American Immigration Detention

Problems and Solutions for American Immigration Detention

Victoria EspinozaUniversity of New Haven  The United States has a tumultuous history on immigration, due to the dich...
Curbing Corruption in Asia and Africa

Curbing Corruption in Asia and Africa: The Effectiveness of Political Will and Anti-Corruption Agencies

Jehad AlyahyaUniversity of New Haven  Corruption is considered a persistent and endemic problem. It has been perceiv...
Organized Crime during COVID-19

Mafia Manipulation: An Analysis of Organized Crime during COVID-19

John S. TarrUniversity of New Haven  Organized crime is a global, structured, and highly centralized enterprise that...
May Colors

EB Professionals Monthly - May 2022

| EBP Monthly
UPCOMING EVENTS TO HELP YOU "Take Momentum Back!"  Working with Employees Onsite & Remote or Both (& Suc...
April colors

EB Professionals Monthly - April 2022

| EBP Monthly
UPCOMING EVENTS TO HELP "Take Momentum Back!" >> Your feedback please regarding this EBP Monthly. Tell us yo...
Quarterly for Evidence-Based Professionals - Volume 6, Number 4

Quarterly for Evidence-Based Professionals - Volume 6, Number 4

| EBP Quarterly
The EBP Quarterly - Volume 6, Number 4 This issue features timely and in-depth research articles. Enjoy... Contempor...
Contemporary Research on the Implementation of Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) Training

Contemporary Research on the Implementation of Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) Training in Corrections

Gregory WadsworthUniversity of New Haven Nearly half a million people were held in psychiatric hospitals and mental ...
Wrongful Convictions and Prisoner Reentry

The Intersection between Wrongful Convictions and Prisoner Reentry: A Look at the Challenges Faced by Exonerees Post-Incarceration

Jane MillerUniversity of New Haven  The phrase “prisoner reentry” is a buzzword and important topic within criminal ...

About EBP Society


EBP Society is the growing community of professionals who share a commitment to the application of evidence-based frameworks to the work we do;

  • By streamlining education and staff development for efficient capacity building
  • Through professional certifications to strengthen career growth, and
  • By providing access to tools and other online resources to ease implementations

Through our online community, organizations and their staff can efficiently access resources that were exclusive to our events. Our members are employed in the health, human, social, and justice services fields.

Quicklinks

Copyright 2020 - EBP Society - All Rights Reserved - Terms & Conditions - Privacy Statement - Cancellation Policy - Society for Evidence-Based Professionals

Contact Us

info@ebpsociety.org

1-770-409-8780

5805 State Bridge Road G #255

Johns Creek, GA 30097

Search our site